Since 2007on the web
Nearly 800reviews published
1 monthof testing, on average
€0received for a score
No quick unboxing
You see plenty of “reviews” that boil down to three steps: I unbox it, I plug it in, it works, great product. At best, that’s a first impression.
You judge a thermostat when winter comes. A robot vacuum, once it has run into the kids’ toys and the cat’s hair. A solar battery, after weeks of clouds and sunshine. A camera, after a few nights outdoors. That takes time, and we take it.
A real home, not a lab
The products we test live with us: a house in the countryside, a family of four, a cat and a garden. Nothing like a lab. The cat goes everywhere, doors are left open and nobody reads the manual.
That’s exactly what interests us. If a product doesn’t work in an ordinary family home, it doesn’t work, however good the spec sheet looks.
How long does a test last?
Usually a month of everyday use, sometimes more. The product replaces what we used before and becomes part of the household routine, with its good days and bad days.
- A smart bulb, plug or sensor joins our home automation setup and our scenes.
- A robot vacuum, mop or mower works every week, in our rooms and on our lawn.
- A battery or solar station is monitored for several weeks to see what it really saves on the bill.
- A mini PC, headphones or a speaker becomes the device we use every day.
The length of each test is shown at the top of the article, in the “The essentials in 30 seconds” box.
I also sometimes come back to a product a year later, to see whether it still works, whether updates kept their promises or whether something gave up.
How we score
Every review ends with a score out of 10, based on several criteria suited to the product: setup, build quality, features, app, battery life, value for money… Strengths and weaknesses are spelled out in the “What we like / What we like less” box.
A score is still an opinion, shaped by our habits and our home. That’s why we always explain why a product won us over or let us down, so you can judge whether our criteria are also yours.
Where do the products come from?
Let’s be honest: I will never be able to afford every product we review. Some are personal purchases. The others come from partnerships with manufacturers and shops, who lend them to us or give them to us. That’s what makes long-term testing possible.
Under the photo of every review, a note tells you whether the product was loaned, given or bought.
Our rule: reviews are not for sale
Loaned, given or bought, it makes no difference to what we say about it.
- No manufacturer or shop can buy a review or a score.
- We alone decide what goes into a review.
- If a product has flaws, we write them down. If it doesn’t work, we say so.
Your trust is the only thing that keeps this site going. It is not for sale.
How the site is funded
Maison et Domotique is an independent site. It is funded by advertising, partnerships and affiliate links: if you buy a product after clicking a shopping link in an article, the shop may pay us a small commission. You pay the same price, and it influences neither which products we test nor their score.
A question about a review?
For a technical question, the forum is the best place to get help. For a comment on an article, a product to test or a partnership, use the contact form: I personally reply to every message.
Cédric Locqueneux, Maison et Domotique
